![rogue one soundtrack scene breakdown rogue one soundtrack scene breakdown](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMjEwMzMxODIzOV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTgwNzg3OTAzMDI@._V1_UY1200_CR90,0,630,1200_AL_.jpg)
It’s 1 min shorter than the original cue - and it’s clear that the cue was shortened by the music editors, since there’s a pretty conspicuous cross fade a few seconds in. The inclusion of an “alternate” (in fact the film version) is something of an anomaly. The Blu-Ray is always there ready to be ripped. The thought process was not "Let's have the end credits but butcher it for the sake of it" but rather "Let's keep it to Giacchino material and include the credits versions of the suites that feature those nice bridges to Williams material".Ĭould they have included the actual End Credits? Yes, of course, but this doesn't mean we have to misunderstand their intentions. If that abrupt intro to track 57 bothers you so much, just do a quick edit on Audacity.Īs for the End Credits, I personally have no reason to be mad for its absence. even if most people just brush them off as identical to the original versions or simply crossfaded short edits.Īs for the issues with the Scarif Antenna Alignment and the "butchered" End Credits I don't really see such big issues. And as I suspected, all the FYC tracks labelled as "FV" do actually have differences.
![rogue one soundtrack scene breakdown rogue one soundtrack scene breakdown](https://static1.colliderimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/rogue-one-final-poster-slice.jpg)
So in short, to have the most out of the currently released music, we need to keep the Expanded and add music from both the OST and FYC. "Alternate Ending" features bridge used in the End Credits from Giacchino to Williams material, absent from OST and FYC "Alternate Open" features bridge used in the End Credits from Williams material to Giacchino suite, absent from OST and FYC "Alternate" features different percussions, absent from OST and FYC
#Rogue one soundtrack scene breakdown full#
Original version with full violin (?) insert missing from Expanded, featured only in the OST "Alternate" in the Expanded has quieter trumpet (?), more integrated with the orchestraįYC features the "Original", OST features the "Alternate"Įxpanded features the FYC version with shorter violin (?) insert that starts at 2:32 "Original" in the Expanded has louder / alternate take trumpet (?)
![rogue one soundtrack scene breakdown rogue one soundtrack scene breakdown](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/b9Y2DbVEs-c/maxresdefault.jpg)
"Alternate" in the Expanded features different ending, absent from OST and FYCĪlternate: short edit + added guitar / synth (?) insert in the openingįYC features the "Alternate", OST features the "Original" Other differences in the Expanded Soundtrack breakdown This is just a quick comparison, there may be more to them, this is just a first-glance look but enough to determine that there are actual differencesĮxpanded features alternate longer opening įYC features a different opening, actually mostly tracked from a later section of the track with a few edits (thanks pointing out)Įxpanded has extended intro absent from FYC įYC cuts the first 23 seconds of Expanded verionįYC features a different opening, actually tracked from a pitch shifted section later in the same track (thanks again pointing out). Other FYC tracks labelled as Film Versions:įor Your Consideration Promo / Expanded Soundtrack differences of aforementioned additional Film Version tracks Original Soundtrack / For Your Consideration Promo differences (not counting short crossfade edits)įYC is labelled as Film Version: short edit + added guitar / synth (?) insert in the openingĪlbum has Original Version: has quieter trumpet (?), more integrated with the orchestra įYC is labelled as Film Version: louder trumpet (?) insert / different take Īlbum has Original Version: full violin (?) insert, starts at 2:21įYC is labelled as Film Version: shorter violin (?) insert starts at 2:32 I see a lot of people missing to list all alternates and differences between the various releases and I think my contributions might be helpful.īefore going in, I have to admit that my ability to name specific instruments if pretty awful so don't be surprised if I wrongly call a trumpet or violin a different instrument and I apologize in advance. I'm new to score-specific threads, as so far I've only been a lurker and made an account only to make contributions to the 2021 FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION Thread.